How to Handle Potential Tips and Leads
Record it, pass it on, and resist the urge to check it yourself.
Record every tip exactly as you receive it, pass it to the investigating agency quickly, and do not follow it up yourself. Never go to an address, confront a person, or pay for information. A tip handled calmly and handed on intact is worth more than one the family has tried to test.
If someone is in immediate danger, call 911. This guide is general information, not legal advice, and procedures differ between states and agencies.
Why families should not investigate tips
The instinct to act is strong. A stranger says they saw your daughter at a gas station forty miles away, and you want to be in the car. Before you go, consider what can go wrong:
- If the person is with someone dangerous, your arrival can put both of you at risk.
- If the person left by choice, a sudden appearance can drive them further away.
- Evidence such as camera footage may be lost or mishandled.
- Witnesses can be influenced by a family’s questions before police speak to them.
- The tip may be a hoax meant to lure or defraud you.
Police can do things with a tip that you cannot: request footage formally, check it against other information, and send an officer who has legal authority.
Record the tip
Use the same format every time.
- Date and time received.
- How it arrived: call, text, comment, in person.
- The tipster’s name, phone number or account, if offered. Do not press an anonymous tipster for identity.
- Exactly what they said, in their words. Screenshot written tips.
- What they saw: when, where, what the person was wearing, who they were with, a vehicle, the direction of travel.
- How sure they are, and why they believe it was the missing person.
If the tipster is on the phone, ask whether they are still at the location and whether the person is still in view. If so, ask them to call 911 immediately and stay where they are.
Pass it on fast
Send the tip to the investigator by the method they asked you to use, and note the time you sent it. For a sighting happening right now, call 911, give the case number, and then tell the investigator.
Pass on everything, including tips you find unlikely. You do not have the whole picture. A detail that seems meaningless to the family may match something police have not shared.
Ask the tipster to call the agency directly as well. A first-hand account is better than a relayed one.
Sort urgent from non-urgent
- Happening now: a current sighting, a person in distress, a threat. Call 911.
- Recent and specific: a sighting within the past day with a place and time. Phone the investigator; if you cannot reach them, call the agency’s dispatch line.
- Older or vague: "I think I saw someone like that last week." Send it in writing.
- Speculation, dreams and psychic impressions: log them and include them in your next routine update. Investigators differ in how they treat these, and that decision is theirs.
Recognize hoaxes and scams
Publicity attracts false tips. Some are honest mistakes. Others are deliberate. Warning signs include:
- A demand for money before information is shared.
- A claim to be holding the person, with a ransom demand.
- Refusal to speak to police.
- Insistence that you come alone to a particular place.
- Details that match only what was in the public post.
- A "private tracker" or "hacker" who offers to find a phone for a fee.
The FBI reports that ransom demands in these schemes commonly run from $5,000 to $10,000 and that the callers typically offer no proof that the person is alive. Do not pay. Save everything and report it to the investigator. See how to avoid missing-person scams.
Use a tip line that is not your own phone
The public appeal should direct tips to the police agency or an established tip line. That keeps your number out of circulation and creates an official record. If tips reach you anyway, thank the person, record the tip, and ask them to call the agency.
Camera footage
Doorbell cameras, shops and buses often overwrite their recordings within days. If you learn that footage may exist, tell the investigator at once, with the address and the time window, and ask them to request it. You can politely ask an owner to save the footage for police. Do not ask them to hand it to you, and do not post clips online without the investigator’s agreement.
When a tip comes to nothing
Most do. Each one that leads nowhere is painful, and that is the usual pattern of an investigation, not evidence that the search is failing. Keep the log going, and let people who are not in the immediate family take the phone shifts when they can.
Where a private investigator fits
A licensed investigator can lawfully follow up certain kinds of leads, such as locating and interviewing a witness or reviewing public records, and should share what they learn with the detective. They are bound by the same cautions about confrontation and interference. See what a licensed private investigator can legally do.
A script for taking a tip by phone
Keep it by the phone so that anyone answering can use it.
- "Thank you for calling. Can I take some details?"
- "When did you see this, and where exactly?"
- "What was the person wearing? Were they with anyone? Was there a vehicle?"
- "Which way were they heading?"
- "What made you think it was them?"
- "May I have your name and number, in case the police want to speak with you? You can stay anonymous if you prefer."
- "Please call [agency] on [number] as well, and give them the case number [X]."
Read the details back before the caller hangs up. Then log the tip and send it on.
Volunteers and online groups
Community groups can generate dozens of tips in an evening, many of them repeating each other. Ask a group’s administrator to pin one instruction: send information to the police line, do not post addresses or accusations, and do not go looking. Accusations made online against a named person can be defamatory, can put that person in danger, and can damage a prosecution if a crime has occurred.
Keeping perspective on sightings
Well-meaning people often report someone who merely resembles the photograph. The more widely an appeal travels, the more of these arrive. The pattern across sightings, whether several independent reports cluster in one place and time, tells police more than any one report does.
Common questions
Someone says they know where my relative is but will only tell me in person. What should I do?
Do not go. Give the person’s details and message to the investigator. A real witness can speak to police; insistence on meeting a family member alone is a warning sign.
Should we offer a reward for tips?
Discuss it with the investigator first. Rewards can bring out real information and also a large number of false tips. If you offer one, route tips through police or a recognized tip line.
What if police do not follow up on a tip?
Ask the investigator what was done with it; there may be reasons they cannot share. If you believe a specific, credible lead is being missed, ask for a supervisor or raise it with your state’s missing-persons clearinghouse.
Sources
- FBI IC3: Scammers Target Families Who Post Missing Persons on Social Media
- NCMEC: Is Your Child Missing?
- NamUs, U.S. Department of Justice
Last reviewed November 2026. Laws and agency procedures change; confirm details with the agency handling your case.
Keep reading
Or return to all 20 guides, the Missing Children page or the Missing Elders page.
Ask Beacon 96 to review a case
Tell us who is missing and what has been done so far. A person reads every request. We will tell you plainly whether we can help, and how.
Submitting a request is not an emergency report and does not notify police. In an emergency call 911.
- You send the requestShare what you know. Most fields are optional.
- We review itWe may contact you to clarify details before deciding.
- We answerIf we accept the case, the Foundation assigns a licensed investigator from its network and pays for the search in full. If we cannot, we say so and point to other resources.